This weekend's first promise of *consistent* warm weather was a welcome experience following an otherwise cold, dreary May. It got me in full time summer mode, which for us here in the Mitten is a pretty big deal. But unfortunately, the sunshine was clouded by MI officials who used a recent meeting as a platform to slam charter schools with virtually no factual basis.
On May 14, the MI State Board of Education’s regular meeting included a discussion of a $47 million federal grant that Michigan had been awarded to expand quality charter schools in the state. This should have been a routine matter, but instead, the Board voted 4-3 against the spending criteria outlined in the grant, essentially freezing the entire plan and holding that money in limbo. Not to mention, some Board Members also used the occasion to launch a full-scale (and wildly ill-informed) attack on charter schools in general.
Despite the fact that Michigan’s K-12 public education system as a whole still continues to lag behind most of the country (whether you're considering district or charter results), Board President Cassandra Ulbrich said that our students don’t deserve any more quality school options.
The fact that we’ve lost 200,000 students over the last 15 years, we still thought we needed $46 million to open new charter schools?” she said. “We have 200,000 fewer students, so why do we have to keep building new schools?”
Even more offensive were the comments from State Board member Michelle Fecteau, who went on a long rant about Michigan’s charter school special education teachers with little to no relation to the federal grant topic at hand.
I’m hearing a remark about how much better they’re going to be on special ed, because honestly, they do a lousy job on special education,” Fecteau said. “Will you ensure that they provide programming for special ed? They’re already taking the easiest-to-teach kids. I just don’t have a lot of faith. It’s been 20-some years, and I just see the data, and it’s just not there for the charter schools.”
And while I'd be happy to sit down with any member of the Board (and really, anyone who questions charter merit) to talk facts, it was apparent that this State Board of Education meeting was not about the facts: it was about condemning MI's charter schools, and it's a tactic that's become all too familiar over these few short weeks.
On the national level, Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders, a candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination, recently released his education plan calling for a national moratorium on charter schools, along with a ban on for-profit operators. Moratoriums and bans like this simply mean charter contracts, both new and renewals, wouldn’t get approved anymore. So these statements are not isolated - and they're cleverly sandwiched between 'facts' that draw broad conclusions on the success of charter schools, the students we serve, the rules we follow, etc. At MAPSA, we find that those 'facts' are easily debunked with widely supported data and polling. And yet, here we are at the same table, engaging in the same arguments - it's utterly frustrating.
Here are some facts that you'll rarely see in the news:
Over 150,000 Michigan students choose a charter school for their public education - and YES, every one of those schools holds a public, nonprofit status. Urban students in places like Detroit and Flint are overwhelmingly served by charter schools, following decades of struggle in district systems. Not to mention, minority populations who are often served in those communities have overwhelming support for charters. A recent poll from Democrats for Education Reform showed that minority democrat voters overwhelming support charter schools.
Our public charter schools matter. Our students matter. Our educators matter. Michigan's public education system can't afford to spread misinformation for the sake of a political agenda, pitting charter against district. We're looking for meaningful, lasting solutions - and charters have earned a seat at the table. I urge our lawmakers to engage in a different conversation. Let's envision where we want MI's public education standard to be, and work together to get there.
We will continue to share our story as MI charter stakeholders. Every child deserves a fair shot to succeed at a school that puts their needs first. I simply ask that our lawmakers and officials listen. This is our line in the freshwater sand - and we won't be ignored.